What are Carbon Zinc Batteries?

Carbon zinc (or zinc carbon) batteries are a single-use battery type that have been around since they were invented by Carl Gassner in 1886. At the time, the carbon zinc battery became the first commercially available dry cell battery we've ever seen.

‍

To this day, these batteries are a reliable and cost-effective source of power. As a repair shop owner for over 17 years, I've personally worked up to my elbows in electronics that use carbon zinc batteries. And if there's one thing I've learned about them in that time, it's that these little batt-boys can be finicky. Luckily, with a few tricks up your sleeve, you can actually coax some serious longevity out of them.

‍

Below, I break down what carbon zinc batteries are, how they're used today, their history and specifications, and what to do with them when you're done using them (thanks to a great video from Sip Ski and EducateTube. Let's dive in!

‍

Carbon Zinc Batteries and Their Common Uses

You may not realize how many batteries you use every day. Every year in the U.S., Americans actually purchase roughly 3 billion dry-cell batteries, some of which include carbon zinc batteries.

‍

Here's a brief run-down of their advantages:

1. Affordability: The main reason for the enduring popularity of these batteries is their low cost, as they are significantly cheaper than their alkaline counterparts. This affordability makes them an attractive choice for budget-conscious consumers and manufacturers, like the customers and developers of smoke alarms.
2. Wide Availability: Carbon zinc batteries are readily available in most stores, from supermarkets to convenience stores, so they are easy to replace (which is critical, since they are not reusable).
3. Leak Resistance: While no battery is completely leak-proof, carbon zinc batteries are far less prone to leakage compared to many other batteries, which makes them safer for devices that don't require frequent usage. This is also why they're great for smoke detectors, because these devices are meant to last up to seven years before being replaced (and carbon zinc batteries can be stored for 1 to 3 years, so ~half the lifespan of a smoke detector).

‍

In addition to smoke detectors, carbon zinc batteries are best suited for other low-drain devices that do not require a constant high current. Some other common applications include:

1. Remote controls
2. Wall clocks
3. Toys
4. Flashlights
5. Radios

‍

By contrast, high-drain situations like digital cameras or gaming controllers are not ideal for carbon zinc batteries. In these scenarios,  alkaline or rechargeable batteries are far superior (and hence why the developers use these batteries instead).

‍

Shelf Life and Storage

When stored properly (that is, in a cool and dry place), carbon zinc batteries can have a shelf life of up to 1-3 years. By contrast, if they are in extreme temperatures and humidity, these batteries will experience reduced performance and leakage.

‍

Here's some more quick and handy facts about Zinc batteries.

History and Development:

• First commercial dry battery developed in 1886 by Carl Gassner, based on wet cell technology by Georges Leclanché
• Gassner's design improved upon the earlier wet cell tech, and ultimately made these batteries the stable, reliable, and portable
• These batteries handheld devices like flashlights possible due to higher energy density and lower cost than previous cells
• Capacity and stability improved over 20th century through purer materials and better sealing

Construction:

• Anode: Zinc can that also serves as container
• Cathode: Mixture of manganese dioxide (MnO2) and carbon powder packed around a carbon rod
• Electrolyte: Acidic paste of ammonium chloride (NH4Cl) or zinc chloride (ZnCl2)
• A Separator layer prevents short circuits between anode and cathode
• They are sealed to prevent electrolyte evaporation
• You can read more about this on the University of Cambridge DoITPoMS site.

Chemical Reactions:

• Anode reaction: Zn + 2 Cl− → ZnCl2 + 2 e−
• Cathode reaction varies based on electrolyte, but generally: 2 MnO2 + 2 e− → Mn2O3
• Produces voltage of about ~1.5V

Types:

• General purpose with ammonium chloride electrolyte
• Heavy-duty/zinc-chloride with zinc chloride electrolyte for longer life and steadier voltage

Performance:

• Low-cost and reliable for low drain devices like remotes and clocks
• Relatively short service life, especially compared to alkaline (which last 4-10x longer)
• Prone to leakage as zinc anode is consumed

Environmental Impact:

• Historically contained mercury; now banned
• Must be properly recycled/disposed of as batteries are considered hazardous waste

In summary, these batteries enabled early portable electronics, and remain a very low-cost option for low-drain devices to this day. However, their limited capacity, shelf-life and propensity to leak have led to replacement by superior chemistries like alkaline batteries in many applications.

‍

How to repurpose a carbon zinc battery

In this informative video, Sip Ski from EducateTube takes us on a fascinating journey into the world of carbon-zinc batteries. He demonstrates how these seemingly simple power sources can be repurposed and their components extracted for various experiments and projects.

Sip Ski begins by showcasing the four main components that can be salvaged from a used carbon-zinc battery:

‍

1. Carbon rods: First there's the rods, which come in different sizes, and can be re-used in a variety of chemical and physics experiments.
2. Manganese dioxide: Then there's this element, which is a black powder compound that's also useful for chemistry experiments and can even serve as a catalyst in certain reactions if you need them.
3. Zinc plates: The zinc plates are next, which can be extracted from the battery casing, and are valuable for re-use in chemical experiments.
4. Steel plates: And finally there's the steel plates, which are often overlooked, but can also be repurposed for practical applications like creating a magnetic surface to hold LED lights in place.

Throughout the video, Sip Ski emphasizes the importance of wearing gloves when handling these components, as some can stain your skin or be potentially harmful if handled improperly.

‍

Next, Sip Ski takes us through a step-by-step process of disassembling a carbon-zinc battery. He notes the differences in quality between brand-name batteries and cheaper alternatives, highlighting the superior materials used in higher-quality batteries.

‍

As he dismantles the battery, Sip Ski points out the various layers and components, including the plastic separator and the paste-like material surrounding the carbon rod, and demonstrates the proper technique to extract the rod, which can be quite fragile and brittle.

‍

It's definitely worth a watch so check it out!